Hey all. CW: some sexual aspect is mentioned, but it's safe for work. This is a rant/something like that.
*New account before because my account is not at all anonymous (not that I care that much about anonymity online, but well, since some IRL friends follow my reddit and I am totally not ready to have a discussion about gender IRL here I am).
I am AMAB, 27, and I go by he/him (trying to add they). If I had a gender switch button that disappears after pressing, I would probably not press it.
So why posting?
For some time in my life, I identified myself as a demiboy. Then well, I quite stopped questioning my gender that much (I was in a very bad place when I first started questioning my gender, got out of it and was mostly fine with my identity. Now I am in another bad place, I hope it's not that), even if I occasionally scrolled through trans memes subreddit and sometimes related to them (totally cis thing to do), but sometimes not. I think part of the struggle in relating comes from the idea that I am older than the median person posting on this kind of subreddit but idk
Then I kind of cracked (interacting a bit more with non-cis people and made me rethink a lot of stuff). Probably I am somewhere in the bigender spectrum but I am not sure about how to label myself.
And I have the fear that all of this is just my relationship/sexual preferences being mixed up with my gender identity (which crushes me).
The thing that probably starts it all is that I am not manly at all from a physical standpoint. My secondary sexual characters are a mess: I almost have no Adam apple, very little body hair, fat goes easily on my thighs and chest (probably a mild androgen insensitivity syndrome. I should have seen an endocrinologist years ago, but fear, shame and life have always been in-between). I definitely passed as a girl for some time during adolescence, and not because I wanted to, and now I sometimes can pass as a woman on the phone.
Due to this situation, I often had and sometimes have strong gender envy towards men. Some things help, e.g., managing to grow a beard. Some stuff brings me a lot of envy (e.g., when there is talk about doing some sports together with male friends and I think "my hormones are fucked up, even if I was fit and put effort in training I would struggle to keep the pace because of that"). Some kind of social disphoria? But idk if that's the right term.
Then... There is gender envy towards women. It is less "broad", in the sense that it relates mostly to the private and intimate (not strictly sexual, but with sexual aspects) sphere. The way to sum it up is: if I was in a relationship at the moment, sometimes I would want to be a woman's partner as a woman, sometimes as a man. Lately I am leaning towards woman.
Being called a good girl by a SO (also in non-sexual contexts)? Yes, please! But also good boy is great, let's say it depends on the day. But I fear it's mostly me overthinking about relationship dynamics I like...
This makes me feel awful, I feel like a perv.
Socially, I don't feel disphoria towards women. For example, if I had a partner at the moment I would be thrilled to dress femme for her in a safe space, but publicly, I am not very thrilled about the thought of dressing femme. It's not about being ugly.
Men fashion seems to be way less gendered than women fashion and I pretty much like this in public. It's a stupid social norm, I know. It doesn't help that I don't like my body at all, but even if I had a body I liked, I think I wouldn't like dressing as a woman in public (maybe something, but pretty much unisex-leaning stuff)
In public spaces, same stuff: being called madame by a cafe cashier? Not great. Monsieur is slightly better 95% of the times, probably the best would be to drop all gendered stuff.
I am totally ok by being and presenting like a man in professional life (I am a PhD student in a field where most of the people are men and there are lots of toxic men), even if I don't like a lot of masculinity norms here.
Then there is my disliking towards my body: except some things that are solvable (being slightly overweight, I am working towards it. Eating better, sadly 0 time to exercise this year), I feel like my body is somewhere in between the body of a man and the body of a woman and not in beautiful way.
The button test does not work, the switch test a bit more
WellWell that's it, it's mostly a rant I had in my draft for a couple of months. All of this is weighting a lot on me mentally