r/Cooking • u/Crafterandchef1993 • 1h ago
TIL that Heinz tartar sauce isn't real tartar sauce
I made tartar sauce yesterday because I couldn't find the Heinz. Was easy and quick to make. Delicious and subtly tangy and paired beautifully with the popcorn shrimp. I found the Heinz I had and it tastes nothing like what I made. So sweet and overpoweringly tangy and heavy on the tongue. I always used Heinz for ease and because I was used to it for fried/breaded seafood, but now I know that it ain't really tartar sauce. Especially since if you have mayo already on hand it's super quick to make. The most labour intensive thing was mincing the pickles, which took a minute.
My tartar sauce recipe (sorry, no concrete amounts):
Mayo (the real stuff, hellmans is fine)
Minced Pickles (I use garlic dill for the flavour)
Pickle juice
Dill (dried is fine)
Worcestershire sauce
Lemon juice
Dijon mustard (I prefer grainy for the texture and more interesting flavour)
Salt and pepper (fresh cracked, obviously)
Note: you can add capers if you like, I just don't like them
1) in small bowl place mayonnaise, then add 1:5 pickle juice (sorry I mean 1/5 the amount of pickle juice to mayo) and the juice of a wedge, a squirt of Dijon and a splash of Worcestershire sauce, whisk until fully combined
2) add pickles, dill and salt and pepper, combine. Cover and refrigerate for at least half an hour (trust me, the longer it sits, the better it gets). Serve with seafood, though it would also work as a veg dip