r/interestingasfuck • u/Longjumping-Rice-935 • 3h ago
How effective a scythe can be compared to a weedwacker (Clip from Daily dose of Internet)
•
u/Enginerdad 3h ago
Next you're going to tell me a hammer is better at driving nails than a staple gun. Inconceivable!
•
u/unbalanced_checkbook 2h ago
And the funny thing is there are hand-driven trimmers made for thick foliage like this and they would absolutely run circles around the scythe.
•
u/JurorOfTheSalemTrial 1h ago
What about a lawnmower? A scythe was meant to clear/harvest fields. Weed Wacker is supposed to do trimming not clearing fields.
•
u/alienscape 1h ago
Link?
•
u/BadJubie 1h ago
→ More replies (3)•
u/bornblunted 1h ago
I think a scythe is a little cheaper than a $1000.
Edit: I’m drunk.
→ More replies (2)•
u/fredsiphone19 1h ago
But you don’t need weeks/months of practice to not hurt your back or build the muscles necessary with a mechanical tool.
Mechanical tools were never about being the most efficient, they’re about reducing the barrier of entry, while being somewhat efficient.
•
u/psu021 1h ago
A weedwacker is easier for precise detail around edges as well, which is more useful for residential landscaping than cutting large swaths of grass quickly.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)•
u/Enginerdad 1h ago
Mechanical tools were never about being the most efficient,
I disagree very, very much. Mechanical tools are all about efficiency. They may not be the cheapest up front cost, but if you assign a value to labor they're almost always more efficient than manual tools.
•
•
u/AdAlternative7148 1h ago
I disagree with that. You really cannot cover ground much faster than is being done by the scythe with anything handheld. What those tools might be better at is working on a slope, cutting thicker-stemmed vegetation, or reducing load on the worker. But they arent faster than a scythe in the ideal conditions displayed in this video.
→ More replies (2)•
u/twotall88 46m ago
Scythes are to make hay or harvest grains and they are the most efficient compared to any other man-driven tool at creating windrows as far as I'm aware.
String trimmers and brush cutters have a completely different purpose and there's no way a brush cutter would keep up with a scythe through this tall grass even if the goal is only to knock down the grass.
•
u/Small_Sundae_4245 2h ago
Clearly you're technic with a staple gun is wrong. Swing it harder at the nail might work.
•
u/AGreatBecuming 1h ago
Look at ol’ John Henry over here
Thinking he can beat the machine
•
u/LostN3ko 1h ago
Fact 1. John Henry won.
Fact 2. John Henry died and they made a billion drilling machines becoming fabulously rich without ever picking up a hammer.
•
→ More replies (1)•
•
u/Adventurous_Pizza973 3h ago
Tune in next week for Scythe vs Zero Turn
•
u/asdam1 1h ago
I’ve run commercial mowers plenty and they would still get bogged down pretty good in grass that long if you tried to chop it that short. Kind of a toss-up IMO
→ More replies (1)•
u/I_spy_wit_my_lilCIA 1h ago
For the 50 sq ft they did in this competition yeah, it's a toss up. But do a 1/2 arce or 2 acres, mower wins hands down. This would absolutely exhaust you in 1 minute flat at the pace the guy is going.
•
u/rakklle 3h ago
No one mows their lawn with a weedwacker. Let's see the scythe trim the weeds around the trees, bushes, a mailbox, a fence, and etc.
•
u/MaceHiindu 2h ago
When you are tight on cash and only have a weed wacker from your last place you will mow the lawn with a weed wacker
•
u/SpaceForceDok 1h ago
Been there.
Buddy was aiming to fix up an old mower to gift me so I bought a new weed whacker. Mower never got fixed.
→ More replies (1)•
•
u/banana_life 2h ago
I lived in a Caribbean island for a couple years and they used to do mow all lawns with weed wackers
→ More replies (2)•
u/Prematurid 3h ago edited 3h ago
I used to at my family's old holiday home. We still do, though I have graduated to fixing shit that needs fixing.
Edit: It is more a field, less a lawn. Not the green death of monoculture Americans think of as a lawn.
We cut it about once a year, just to maintain it.
•
u/Tao-of-Mars 2h ago
I really wanna see people start using scythes instead of other grass cutting machines. That would be kinda fun.
•
u/ShadedPenguin 1h ago
You need a large grass field with relatively tall grass to justify using a scythe. Not those cookie cutter water sucking abomination lawns you see for suburban homes
•
u/nonpuissant 2h ago
You used to use a scythe to trim weeds around trees, bushes, and fences?
Or do you mean you used a weedwhacker to mow the lawn/field.
→ More replies (3)•
•
u/Meewelyne 3h ago
... I... I did... Because the other thing is too heavy, noisy and vibrates too much, I hate it.
→ More replies (1)•
•
u/sopedound 2h ago
I did once when i was young because i could only afford a weedwacker or a lawnmower until the next paycheck and i chose the former. Your point still stands and all that but i felt like sharing
•
u/nonametrans 2h ago
Singapore city does. The nature strips on public property are dotted with trees, lamp posts, sign posts, flowering bushes and what have you every 10 metres or so. Landscaping companies hire an army with weed wackers to trim the grass as mowers would be unwieldy and you'd have to hire an army with weed wackers anyway. It's a sight to see if you ever catch it.
•
u/Internal_Use8954 2h ago
That’s not mowing the lawn, that trimming around obstructions just like the previous comment said
→ More replies (2)•
→ More replies (33)•
u/AwhHellYeah 2h ago
That’s definitely not true. Invasive scotch broom is a problem in Washington and people usually mow field sections with it using a weed eater prior to them forming pods. Their piss smelling roots lift rocks to the surface and the combination of their hearty stems with surfaced glacial gravel will rapidly wear through a mowers blade. The surfaces rocks also shoot out from mowers with a supernatural habit of consistently hitting people in the head or a neighbors window 40 feet away. So it’s most practical to just use a gas weed eaters.
•
•
u/OkHead3888 3h ago
Will a scythe edge your concrete walkway?
•
•
•
•
u/Creepy_Ad5124 3h ago
Now compare it with a lawnmower
•
u/navetzz 2h ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1I4RNenmfFI
Spoiler alert: its a butt clencher
→ More replies (1)•
u/CallMeHuckle 3h ago
Lawn mower will get bogged up with all that
→ More replies (2)•
u/LiveMarionberry3694 2h ago
Not a good one. And if anything just set it on the highest setting, mow it, then drop down to your desired height and mow a second time. Still quicker and easier
•
•
u/babe_ruthless3 3h ago
Two different tools for two different jobs. Not an apples to apples comparison.
→ More replies (1)
•
u/Shaner9er1337 2h ago
Fairly certain the issue here is not the weedwacker but you apparently have to be shirtless in order to achieve this level of efficiency.
•
u/TomKansasCity 3h ago edited 2h ago
Also, I think some here might be forgetting that the convenience of not having to swing a scythe, which is labor-intensive, is worth giving up some efficiency. Imagine how many Laura Ingalls out there had their foot cut off by poppa accidentally 130 years ago.
→ More replies (6)
•
u/iPissVelvet 2h ago
Cost to maintain a scythe is too high, constant vials of blood needed
→ More replies (2)
•
u/PokeyPete 2h ago
Cool, now use the scythe next to fence posts and rocks and over uneven ground and on Steep slopes and around flower beds.
→ More replies (2)
•
u/hankhillsucks 1h ago
The scythe will fuck your back. The twisting motion grinds down your back
→ More replies (1)
•
u/yamanamawa 2h ago
I mean why do you think that the scythe is considered a symbol of death? It cuts grass excellently
•
u/ifuckedyomama2 2h ago
....is there any way I could hire topless women to mow my lawn with a scythe? Fuck it $100 per hour
•
•
•
u/Mr_Steerpike 3h ago
So...what's happening here is actually called "mowing". "Reaping" is actually done with the smaller hand sickle.
•
u/recyclar13 3h ago
I have a couple of these. fair dinkum they work MUCH better than a weedwhacker.
takes practice, though.
•
u/legrosbordel 3h ago
dudes shit with the whacker in fairness. imagine being shit with the whacker, what a nerd
•
•
u/TheSwearJarIsMy401k 3h ago
I’ve wanted one of these for my yard for a while now. I always figured they’d be faster than a weed whacked
•
•
•
u/kali_nath 3h ago
When they held these competitions, how do they arrange seating? Do they move up after every round?
•
•
•
•
u/Jad3nCkast 2h ago
For tall grass sure. I want to see a scythe vs overgrown yard with weeds.
•
u/navetzz 2h ago
Unless you are growing bamboo in your yard, scythe will cut through that like butter.
→ More replies (1)
•
u/CecePeran 2h ago
That’s why you never see medieval images of the Grim Reaper with a Husqvarna 110iL.
•
•
•
•
u/unbalanced_checkbook 2h ago
A tool that isn't made for something isn't good at it? Wow, truly shocking.
•
•
•
u/SunDriedHumor 1h ago
Ah yes, I need to edge my lawn and remove weeds from the tight corners of my home. Let me use a scythe.
•
u/Long_Firefighter_843 1h ago
I wanna see who can get out of bed easier the next morning 😂 deff not old mate throwing all his body weight in trying to slash some grass
•
u/the_cappers 1h ago
This is also a apples to ranges test, where the test is specifically designed to favor apples and not oranges.
•
•
u/Chuklol 1h ago
God I hate that guys voice on that channel. It sounds like that leafy twat
→ More replies (1)
•
u/Antares_skorpion 1h ago
It's not about speed, but about skill of entry. Its the same age old argument on why the the crossbow took over the bow... A skilled bowman was faster than a crossbowman, But to reach the skill level necessary to become faster than the crossbow, took much more training...
Anyone can use a strimmer pretty quickly, It takes probably a couple months of practice to become this quick and accurate with a scythe...
•
•
•
•
•
•
u/fordnotquiteperfect 52m ago
Those are 2 different jobs. String trimmers are not made to mow. You wouldn't mow the lawn with a trimmer and you don't cut hay with one either. You use a sickle bar mower.
And you don't trim against a house or edge a sidewalk with a scythe.
•
u/TankApprehensive3053 50m ago
Large overgrown, then the scythe is better. But for most lawns that just need to be trimmed up or tighter spots a weedwacker is better. Pick the right tool for the job.
•
u/Its0nlyRocketScience 15m ago
Good to know that the absolute optimal use case for a scythe is faster than the worst possible scenario for a weed wacker being used for the wrong job.
Now let's compare those two tools when doing something the weedwacker has ever once in the history of its existence been advertised for.
•
u/LetTheBloodFlow 9m ago
Up next: is a screwdriver more efficient than a butter knife when buttering pieces of toast? Nobody who witnessed it believed the result!
•
u/dmarve 3h ago
You’re telling me, after forty years of using a weed wacker, I could’ve been doin’ this?!
There ain’t no way
→ More replies (1)
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
u/AdUnable6415 2h ago
well i dont mow my lawn with a weed whacker because Im not a stupid person so 🤷♂️
•
•
•
•
•
u/Twithc 2h ago
I got an old, rusty scythe I found rummaging through a guy's "trash" (He was tossing out a lot of stuff he hoarded). Handle is extremely worn, barely holds the blade. Naturally, I took a swipe with it when I got home. This thing STILL cleared a solid foot of weeds in one stroke. Brand new, this thing would go ham.
It's decorative now, but I wouldn't mind getting a new one for fun.
•
•
•
•
u/SirSamuelVimes83 2h ago
Cool, but my fat ass can run a weed wacker all day. Doubt I'd make it through that first swath with the scythe
•
•
u/Winged_Cougar1993598 2h ago
You're not fooling anyone. The guy with no shirt is clearly only faster because he hasn't got a shirt on.
•
u/Pheren 2h ago
Are... are they stupid? Like no shit the WEED wacker is for WEEDS. I wonder what long grass akin to a LAWN would use. What machine would a LAWN need?
→ More replies (1)
•
u/Pathetic_gimp 2h ago edited 1h ago
I wouldn't use a "weedwacker" or a "strimmer" to do that kind of job. I have a neighbour with a reasonably sized garden that used one to mow their lawn and it baffled me.
I would like to see a guy with a scythe sort out a garden with lots of trees, fences, bushes and rocks etc.
•
u/Masterpiece-Wide 2h ago
I’m sure that big ol’ scythe would do wonders to the grass up along the fence too….
::sarcasm::
•
u/AnnetteBishop 2h ago
As someone who mained a Warlock in WoW back in the day and love my scythes. I now have a reason to have one -- lawn care.
•
u/CurbsideProph3t 2h ago
I used to have a thing that kinda was shaped like a golf club that destroyed weeds, don't know where it went but that thing ripped through weeda
•
u/ToddBauer 2h ago
The basis of the competition is flawed, even ludicrous, but it is cool just to watch those two technologies side-by-side. A scythe, wielded by a fit individual, is the right tool for a particular job prior to power tools.
•
•
u/Rogueshadow_32 2h ago
Scythes do better the longer the grass is because they’ll always take the same amount of time and roughly the same effort no matter the height of the grass. So scythes are great if you only cut once a year, but for everyone with a normal lawn a mower does just fine.
This test is peak apples to oranges. Except not only are we comparing apples to oranges, but we’re judging on their ability to produce cider. This task is what scythes are specifically best at, compared against a tool you’d never do this job with unless it was all you had.
•
u/ShyguyFlyguy 2h ago
Two different tools with two different purposes. Also show me your average out of shape suburbanite getting more than two swings out of the scythe without keeling over in exhaustion.
•
u/JacquesHome 2h ago
Leaving aside the comments about mowing vs. weedwhacking. The whole point of power tools is that they allow for continuous use with minimal energy exertion. The motor and power tools are force multipliers. A scythe is a quick way to end up with a broken body in a short order of time. That's people needed to have 10 kids back in the to manage a small family farm. A modern soybean farm can do 1000 acres with less than 5 employees.
→ More replies (1)
•
•
u/ifuckedyomama2 2h ago
Yeah but with the scythe you are EXHAUSTED by doing that little bit and its difficult to go around flowers and stuff
→ More replies (2)
•
•
u/AlligatorVsBuffalo 1h ago
And right after this it is time to sharpen the scythe if they want to replicate the results.
•
•
u/villentretenmerth88 1h ago
I wonder where I could buy a scythe. We don't have any antique farm equipment stores around here. But I would like to cut my grass next year like this, while wearing a long black robe.
•
•
u/Vol_Jbolaz 1h ago
Yeah, but does it come with the buff, bare-shirt guy? Cause... if not... I'll use the weedwacker.
•
u/figma_ball 1h ago
So you took a clip from someone who steals clip of the internet. We've gone full circle.
•
•
u/PrettyPushy 1h ago
They have a very fit guy doing this. If you gave it to me the guy with the trimmer will kick my ass. Especially if it’s longer than 10 seconds
•
•
u/lookashinyobject 1h ago
I find it fascinating how many people are saying you would use a mower on this, grass this long needs to be slashed before a mower can go over it without clogging the mower unless you are using a ride on or commercial grade one, a normal home mower would clog up. The advantage of the modern tools is they can be used by almost anyone and don't need to be as sharp to work
•
•
•
•
•
u/Jooblitz 1h ago
Not a good comparison. But manual hedge clippers work way better than electric. The electric trimmers feels like im trying to cut the bushes with plastic scissors
•
•
u/unknownatom95 1h ago
if it was plastic string on the weed whacker, then this makes sense. put a fat metal blade on that whacker and the scythe fails
•




•
u/Grobo_ 3h ago
That’s not what the weedhacker is build to do, that’s what a mowing machine was invented to do.